Switch inter-connectivity question

Good day to all.  We have a small LAN with less than 10 switches total.  Including all the network printers and PCs and servers there are about 70 nodes in this building.  In the data room, there are (6) 24-port Catalyst switches.  I am trying to determine the best way to inter-connect them.  2 of the switches are c3750x and are stacked.  2 are C3560X and cannot be stacked, and the other 2 are C2960G and cannot be stacked.  Also, there is a C2960G in another building connected to one of these 6 via a 1G uplink.  I wish I had gotten more of the switches with stack capability, but at the time I was not aware of the advantages of stacking.
So... The 2 C3560X switches each have a 10-G network module installed.  One of the 2 3750X's (the stack master, call it Switch-A), in the stack has a 10G module as well.  In a perfect world, I would take the C3560X (the one that is layer-3 with routing enabled and also the default gateway), and connect all the other switches to that one, and use both the 10-gigabit uplinks and then use 1-G uplinks for the rest.  But if I use the 10-G ports, then I cannot use the other 2 1G SFP ports in the network module.  So I am limited to 2 10-G uplinks per C3560 switch.  I can't connect all the other switches to this one unless I used some of the standard (non-SFP) ports.
So here is the way I have it set up right now: there is a 1-G fiber uplink from another building and the fiber is FDDI so it is not possible to use a 10-G uplink between the buildings; they are too far apart for FDDI.  We might run some OM3 fiber later, but for now, the 1-G uplink is the best we can do.  So the 2 buildings are connected using a gigabit fiber uplink with SFP ports, and the fiber coming from the other building is connected to the C3560 that is not the default gateway.  The default gateway switch, call it switch-1, is using both the 10-G uplinks and has one 10-G port connected to the master in the 2-switch stack, (one of the C3750X's, call it Switch-A).  The other 10-G uplink goes to the other C3560X, call it Switch-2 (Switch-2 is the one with the fiber uplink from the other building).  Switch B is the stack slave and is only connected via the stack cables.  The other 2 switches are C2960G-24TC-L and one is connected to Switch-A with a 1-G copper SFP uplink, call it Switch-3, and Switch3 is connected to the other C2960G with a 1-G copper uplink.  I have attached a basic diagram.
So... my question is, without spending more money, is this the best way to connect them?  I could use more of a hub and spoke topology if I did not stick to SFP ports for all the up-linking.  It was my understanding that the SFP ports are the best ones to use for uplinks.  But due to the limitations of the network modules, I could not connect more than 2 SFP uplinks from a given switch, or 3 in some cases where only 1G uplinks were used.
If we did not mind spending a few more thousand (I would love to run OM3 between the buildings and get the speed up to 10G), so if we had another 5 to $10,000 to spend, would it be worth getting a switch full of fast SFP modules and using it to uplink all the other switches (a total of 5 counting the link from the other building and not counting Switch-B since it connects via the stack)?  Everything is working well, so it might be better to leave it alone.  Any helpful comments and/or suggestions are welcomed with a heaping helping of sincere appreciation!
Thanks!
Flux

Disclaimer
The Author of this posting offers the information contained within this posting without consideration and with the reader's understanding that there's no implied or expressed suitability or fitness for any purpose. Information provided is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as rendering professional advice of any kind. Usage of this posting's information is solely at reader's own risk.
Liability Disclaimer
In no event shall Author be liable for any damages whatsoever (including, without limitation, damages for loss of use, data or profit) arising out of the use or inability to use the posting's information even if Author has been advised of the possibility of such damage.
Posting
What you might consider is using your dual 3750X stack as the physical core and as the L3 router.  All your other switches (except the off-site switch) would have dual port channel links, one link to each 3750X.  This provides core and L3 redundancy and can provide more inter switch bandwidth.
For you critical single home devices, such as your Internet and off-site switch connections, you can have a logical configuration "mirror" port ready on the second 3750X stack member, so if the member with the active link fails, you only need to repatch.  (This can also be use for other critical single homed servers).
On a 3560X/3750X switches you do want to use the SFP ports for your busy ports (because they have their own reserved hardware buffers).  However, if you use 10g port, as 10g, you lose half your SFP ports.  Without knowing your expected traffic flow patterns, I cannot not say whether using all the SFP ports for dual gig port-channels would be better than having some on copper edge ports and some as dual 10g fiber ports.

Similar Messages

  • Switch stack connectivity question

    x.x.x.10 = stack 1
    x.x.x.11 = stack 2
    my question since i have been thrown to the wolves is (with very little experience): I am at one site with 2 stacks. Is connecting stack 1 to stack 2 done with a crossover or straight through cable? On stack 1 I have 6/0/19 and 6/0/20 being used for avaya vm erver and avaya ip office. So I need to make sure that second stack can communciate to number 1 in order for the prots on the second stack to recognize the vm server and ip office locations. I'm a little confused. I know I shouldn't use a stackwise cable. Any help would be appreciated.

    Not to be overly technical or picky, the term "stack" refers to the feature that the 3750 is capable of and stacking this platform would require a "stackwise" cable. It should come with the switch and it's silver. you connect the 3750 through stack port in the back of this switch. Now, if you are simply connecting two switches together, you will require a cross-over cable. A good rule of thumb is when connecting two alike devices you will need cross-over, like router to router or switch to switch. If they are not alike then you will need straight.

  • How to inter connect the javascript and database?

    how to inter connect the java script nad database?
    == User Agent ==
    Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 2.0.50727)

    Which database?

  • Cisco sg 100d unmanaged switch not connecting to network

    I have a Cisco sg 100d-08 unmanaged switched that had been working just fine for several months  but now devices attached to the network thru are no longer on the network.  All lights are on indicating the ports are active.  Tried power recycle but no joy. When I replaced the switch with an old Belkin model everything works fine.  Is there anyway to reset this unmanaged switch or do I now just have an expensive paper weight?

    When the management interface is part of VLAN x
    Make sure that the management interface vlan id is set to 0  (untagged ) If the native vlan on the switch trunk connected to controller is vlan x. If the native vlan is something else make sure to tag the mangement interface vlan with x.
    Another interesting thing that might happen with switch having the following command enabled:
    SW(config)#dot1q tag native
    In that case all trunk native vlan frames will be tagged , so you have to tag the management vlan on the controller as well in that case.
    To be able to troubleshoot such connectivity problem, you should get the output of:
    show run int
    show interface <\\ > switchport
    the latter command should be your best friend.
    One recommondation, make sure to tag your management / ap-manager interface with vlan id  to maintain QoS limiting based on dot1p values for downstream traffic from the wired side.
    In the above scenario , If you can provide the output of show interface <\\> switchport
    I should tell you why the recommended action solved your issue based on the above explanation, and if you would like I can maitain the tag for you.
    Please Don't Forget to rate correct Answers

  • How can I switch the connection pool dynamically during on load happens

    HI,
    I have two data bases which holds same data. i.e Prod_db, Prod_db1,
    I want to switch the connection pool dynamically during load happens
    Ex: During load happens i want to hit prod_db1, after load completes i want to hit prod_db. How to achieve this.

    create dynamic repository variable for DSN using init block so that value is changes based on your timings and use this in connection pool.
    If you use same user and passwords for both the databases that would be easy or else need to follow the same for uid and pwd.
    That should work, if not update.
    If helps pls mark correct/helpful

  • [SOLVED] pulsuadio and blutooth auto switch to connected device?

    Is there a way to stream audiochannels automatically to a bluetooth speaker when it is connected?
    At the moment I have to change manually in pavucontrol Playback section. Otherwise sound is still played via internal speakers..
    Any ideas? Thanks!
    Last edited by miro279 (2015-02-03 14:03:54)

    running:
    plasma-framework 5.6.0-2
    libbluedevil-frameworks 5.2.0-1
    bluedevil-frameworks 5.2.0-1
    bluez 5.27-1
    bluez-libs 5.27-1
    bluez-utils 5.27-1
    sbc 1.3-1
    pulseaudio 5.0-1
    pulseaudio-alsa 2-3
    The bluetooth speaker is a Denon Envaya mini, connected in A2DP mode.
    The whole setup is not working realy stable at the moment, sometimes the device is connecting just fine and I see it in pulseaudio, sometimes it doesn't and bluetooth is crashing when trying to connect. Same is true for trying with bluetoothctl, so I guess it's not a plasma problem.. I also tried gut versions for most of the packages (at least for pulseaudio, libbluedevil-frameworks and bluedevil-frameworks).
    Anyway. even when connecting is successfull, I still have to set the audiostream manually to the speaker with pavucontrol.
    I tried to load pulsaudio module-switch-on-connect in default.pa but didn't see a difference.. I'm guessing this should only autoconnect the speaker when present, but what I'd like to do is to automaticly stream audio to the speaker when connected, not to the internal laptop speaker..
    Last edited by miro279 (2015-02-03 11:18:03)

  • Communicating with xstring to Oracle Inter Connect

    Hello,
    We're using Oracle Inter Connect to communicate between SAP and other applications. To do so, we build remote enabled function modules.
    We now have the problem that Inter Connect does not find RFC's which have parameters which are reffered as TYPE (fe i_matnr type matnr).
    We want to use the xstring as importing and exporting parameter, but we can not refer to it as LIKE (fe i_matnr like mara-matnr).
    Does anyone have expirience with this problem or has a solution?
    Regards,
    John

    No suggestions?

  • NW 7.2 Visual Composer - Switch off connection pooling

    Hello,
    I'd like to switch off connection pooling for a VC app running on NW CE 7.2. I found some entries in destination management for my destination system accordingly (pool size, max time .... and an option to switch it off).
    But it doesn't work. Any ideas why not?
    Thanks very much for your help.
    Regards
    Stefan

    Hello,
    thanks for the answer, but it's not working as expected.
    I thought if connection pooling is switched off that the connection is closed when the user logs off or navigates to a different iView (without backend connection).
    This doesn't happen.
    Am I wrong in my understanding?
    Thanks
    Stefan

  • RV180W loses port forwarding rules when switching WAN connections

    We have a backup WAN connection in our office, but we switch this connection manually on our RV180W when the primary goes down. Our normal connection is ADSL with PPPoE, and the backup is Cable with DHCP.
    However, we also have some port forwarding rules for our VoIP PBX (UDP port 5060) as well as SSH, and these rules seem to stop working completely when we switch our WAN connection to our cable connection. We can still surf the web from our workstations, but our incoming phone calls and SSH connections all cease to work completely. The problem does not persist after we've switched back to our normal ADSL connection.
    This behaviour is completely bizarre and suggests that there's some kind of bug in the Cisco RV180W.

    helm,
    I'm sorry, I wasn't clear which IP address renewal I am speaking about.
    I believe that the problem is caused when the router renews the WHS's local IP address (192.168...). My WAN IP address remains unchanged througout the tests I performed and the problems I experienced.
    The very act of changing the local clients' lease time in the router's configuration causes the forwarding to be lost immediately. (I am gusessing that when the lease time is changed, the router immediately renews the lease and begins a new countdown.)
    (In fact, I might go as far as to say it is a bug in the firmware, but I haven't done enough testing to nail it down.)

  • Help urgently needed please ! My Iphone 4 is on silent vibration mode, received a call and has frozen with the Iphone unusable and yet vibrating. I have tried switching off, connecting to power, connecting to laptop and removing SIM card ???

    Help urgently needed please ! My Iphone 4 is on silent vibration mode, received a call and has frozen with the Iphone unusable and yet vibrating. I have tried switching off, connecting to power, connecting to laptop and removing SIM card ???

    Problem solved... just saw the answer in another thread... https://discussions.apple.com/message/13110222#13110222

  • Switching to connected mode

    according to the docs i should be able to switch between connected and disconnected mode at any time
    However!
    When I try to switch to connected mode I get this error
    "SOA is not set. SOA must be set before switching to Connected Mode. (35519)"
    anyone know where do I set the SOA ? anyone know what the SOA is ?

    SOA = Sun Online Account which is now your MOS (My Oracle Support) ID/password. Go to Administration->Edit Authentications, and you should see a place to enter your MOS user and password.
    Then you should be able to switch to connected mode. Note there is also a HTTP Proxy configuration option there under Administration if you need to set that.

  • SG 300-28 28-Port Gigabit Managed Switch -Lan connectivity issues

    Hello,
    Our office lan running on 2 * SG 300-28 28-Port Gigabit Managed Switch.
    PID VID:SRW2024-K9 V01
    Firmware Version (Active Image):1.0.0.27
    The users are seeing there connection to fileservers(mapped network drives) slowing down over the period.
    We have to re-boot the offending switch to get the normal traffic back.
    I have raised a ticket with cisco small business people and they said to upgrade the firmware to latest version.
    But I am wondering why I need to upgrade this switch as the other switch which also brought at the same time with the same spec have no such issues.
    Even if I decided to upgrade the firmware, they have recommended that I need to reset the switch to factory settings and try to put the previous configuration manually which is a worry for me.
    I have logged on to the web console and I have found out, I can use TFTP or HTTP to backup the config,how do I use those services and what parameters i need to pass those to work, does using that functionality can rollback the switch to previous running configuration?
    PS: Both the switch have connected together using a FC trunk with link aggregation eanbled.So how do I get all those settings back if I upgrade/rollback?
    I just have to come up with some solution as it is affecting the business, so any help would be much appreciated.
    Please see the attachment and let me know if any other info needed?
    Thanks in advance,
    Regards
    Suji

    Hi,
    Please see the difference between the connected switches configuration.
    Maybe the vlan 10 and 30 has been created wrongly.
    Please see the config for both the switches and give me some advice/suggestions.
    I really appreciate that.
                                  Bad Switch Config
    /* This is the config for the bad switch */
    interface port-channel 1
    flowcontrol auto
    exit
    interface port-channel 2
    description netAppFiler1
    exit
    interface port-channel 3
    description Switch
    flowcontrol auto
    exit
    port jumbo-frame
    vlan database
    vlan 10,30
    exit
    interface ethernet g12
    switchport trunk native vlan 10
    exit
    interface ethernet g24
    switchport trunk native vlan 30
    exit
    interface vlan 10
    name Private
    exit
    interface vlan 30
    name "Private 2"
    exit
    voice vlan oui-table add 0001e3 Siemens_AG_phone________
    voice vlan oui-table add 00036b Cisco_phone_____________
    voice vlan oui-table add 00096e Avaya___________________
    voice vlan oui-table add 000fe2 H3C_Aolynk______________
    voice vlan oui-table add 0060b9 Philips_and_NEC_AG_phone
    voice vlan oui-table add 00d01e Pingtel_phone___________
    voice vlan oui-table add 00e075 Polycom/Veritel_phone___
    voice vlan oui-table add 00e0bb 3Com_phone______________
    port-channel load-balance layer-2-3
    interface range ethernet g(25-26)
    channel-group 2 mode on
    exit
    interface range ethernet g(27-28)
    channel-group 3 mode on
    exit
    interface range ethernet g(27-28)
    lacp timeout short
    exit
    interface range ethernet g(1-26)
    lacp port-priority 2
    exit
    ip dhcp relay address 192.168.0.1
    ip dhcp relay enable
    ip dhcp information option
    interface vlan 1
    ip dhcp relay enable
    exit
    bonjour service enable csco-sb
    bonjour service enable http  
    bonjour service enable https 
    bonjour service enable ssh   
    bonjour service enable telnet
    hostname switchbad
    line console
    exec-timeout 0
    exit
    line ssh
    exec-timeout 0
    exit
    line telnet
    exec-timeout 0
    exit
    username admin password xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx level 15 encrypted
    no snmp-server enable
    snmp-server location "Server Rack"
    ip http exec-timeout 0
    ip https exec-timeout 0
    clock timezone 1
    clock dhcp timezone
    ip name-server  192.168.0.1 192.168.0.9
    snmp-server set rlAutomaticClockSetFromPCEnabled  rlAutomaticClockSetFromPCEnabled true
                             Good Switch Config
    /* Good switch run config *
    interface port-channel 1
    description Switch
    flowcontrol auto
    exit
    port jumbo-frame
    lacp system-priority 2
    voice vlan oui-table add 0001e3 Siemens_AG_phone________
    voice vlan oui-table add 00036b Cisco_phone_____________
    voice vlan oui-table add 00096e Avaya___________________
    voice vlan oui-table add 000fe2 H3C_Aolynk______________
    voice vlan oui-table add 0060b9 Philips_and_NEC_AG_phone
    voice vlan oui-table add 00d01e Pingtel_phone___________
    voice vlan oui-table add 00e075 Polycom/Veritel_phone___
    voice vlan oui-table add 00e0bb 3Com_phone______________
    port-channel load-balance layer-2-3
    interface range ethernet g(27-28)
    channel-group 1 mode on
    exit
    interface range ethernet g(27-28)
    lacp timeout short
    exit
    interface range ethernet g(1-26)
    lacp port-priority 2
    exit
    interface port-channel 1
    switchport protected-port
    exit
    ip dhcp relay address 192.168.0.1
    ip dhcp relay enable
    ip dhcp information option
    bonjour service enable csco-sb
    bonjour service enable http  
    bonjour service enable https 
    bonjour service enable ssh   
    bonjour service enable telnet
    hostname switchbaebf1
    line console
    exec-timeout 0
    exit
    line ssh
    exec-timeout 0
    exit
    line telnet
    exec-timeout 0
    exit
    aaa authentication enable Console local
    aaa authentication enable SSH local
    aaa authentication enable Telnet local
    aaa authentication login Console local
    aaa authentication login SSH local
    aaa authentication login Telnet local
    line telnet
    login authentication Telnet
    enable authentication Telnet
    password xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx encrypted
    exit
    line ssh
    login authentication SSH
    enable authentication SSH
    password xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx encrypted
    exit
    line console
    login authentication Console
    enable authentication Console
    password xxxxxxxxxxxxxx encrypted
    exit
    username admin password xxxxxxxxxxxxxx level xy encrypted
    ip ssh server
    snmp-server location "Comms rack"
    ip http exec-timeout 0
    ip https server
    ip https exec-timeout 0
    clock summer-time recurring eu
    sntp unicast client enable
    sntp unicast client poll
    sntp broadcast client enable
    sntp server xx.yyy.zz.70 poll
    sntp server zz.yyy.xx.201 poll
    sntp server zz.yy.xxx.2 poll
    sntp server xzz.xxx.xy.149 poll
    clock dhcp timezone
    ip name-server  192.168.0.1 192.168.0.9
    ip telnet server
    snmp-server set rlAutomaticClockSetFromPCEnabled  rlAutomaticClockSetFromPCEnabled true
    Regards
    Smith

  • Vlan & Inter Vlan question

    Here is my network layout:
    I have a cable modem connecting to a Linksys WRT54GL (DDWRT) router. Port 1 on the WRT54GL is connect to port 01 on the SG300-10 switch.
    On the SG300-10 I've created two Vlans (Vlan 30 & Vlan 40). I assigned ports 3 & 4 on the SG300-10 to Vlan 30 and ports 5 & 6 to Vlan 40. Vlan 30 has the IP Address 10.10.30.1 and Vlan 40 has an Address of 10.10.40.1. The default Vlan (Vlan1) has an Address of 10.10.20.2. The default gateway (WRT54GL router) has an Address of 10.10.20.1. I have also enable DHCP relay on the switch and enter the command "ip routing". My question is on either vlan if I wanted to setup static addresses for clients would I use the 10.10.20.1 (WRT54GL) address as the default gateway? Also, what additional configurations do I need to make for the Vlans to be able to talk to each other and be able to access the internet?
    Thanks,

    Van,
    Thanks for the reply. The SG300-10 is in layer 3 mode. I have configured the DHCP server accordingly. Here is my setup:
                       cable modem
                              |
                              |
                       linksys wrt54gl (10.10.20.1)
                              |
                              |
                       sg300-10  Vlan1=  10.10.20.2 (manage)
                                      Vlan30= 10.10.30.0 /24 (GW= 10.10.30.1)
                                      Vlan40= 10.10.40.0 /24 (GW= 10.10.40.1)
    You said that for inter-Vlan to work I need to set the clients GW to the switch. Would that be the Vlan's gateway for clients in each vlan? For example if a client was in vlan30 their gw would be 10.10.30.1?
    The clients are not able to access the internet from the vlan. How would I configure the static on the switch for the vlans to be able to access the internet? Would this work:  ip route 0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 10.10.20.1?

  • 1.5 mile AP to WGB connection questions

    Hello all.  I am new to the forum and have just enough networking skills to be dangerous. A+ and Net+ Certs in 2000.  Self taught on my AP's and I am now finally to the point that I need help.  Bare with me.
    I have 2 Cisco 1200 G AP's connecting 2 different locations.  Location A ( La ) I have a RVO82 router connected to a 50Mbit cable connection.  I have an AP setup there using a 1 Watt booster and a 24db wire grid directional antenna. Only one antenna here, the other disabled. 
    At Location B  (Lb ), about 1.5 miles away, with good to excellent line of site, i have the other setup as a WGB with a 15db wire grid directional antenna with a 1 Watt booster.  Also only one antenna here, the other disabled.
    WGB feeds a simple 8 port switch and in that switch i have a simple belkin wireless router setup as an AP for Lb's wireless access, which is the most used segment.  (i will usually take all the freebies i can get, lol)
    The signal strenght between the two locations is -49 to -52 db, depending on what time of day I check it.
    I have had this setup for a couple of years now.  I recently switched from a 3Mbit DSL connection to the 50Mbit cable connection hoping to increase my bandwidth with no luck.
    When I first set this up i had a 6Mbit cable connection and it maxxed out at 5 Mbit at Lb.  I thought i would be able to add more boosters and antennas as time went on to go from half duplex to full duplex (the way i think of it is one antenna receiving and the other sending, at both locations) so that when our ISP had faster rates available, i could upgrade. I recently read somewhere on the net that it is not possible to run full duplex in the AP to WGB setup i have.  Is that true?
    My main concern is increasing bandwidth on the WGB side Lb.  When i upgraded to 50Mbit, i still only max out at 5mbit at Lb.  Before i thought it was due to not being full duplex or weaker signal strengths (I've always had the 1watt booster at Lb, then i added one later to La with no benefit noticed except signal strength is better and uploads seem faster from Lb....)  I always use speedtest.net to test the speeds.  Pings from Lb to speedtest is 37ms.  Websites are pretty fast and i have been very happy at Lb.  I wanted to ask everyone here if its possible with what i have to increase bandwidth or not, or ask for other options to achieve it.  Like i said, i am happy with 5Mbit.  But i am paying for 50 and want to see how far that rabbit hole will go.  Any ideas?
    And i have more questions as well, leading into multiple routers and subnets spurring from Lb with their own AP's, but that is more for play and my own curiosity...  12 years later i have a great job and finally have some play money to use a tad of that Net+ but i've forgotten most of it.
    ....but thats it for now as i will wait to see if everyone calls me retarded or not before posting again.  Thanks in advance ALL.

    One of these days i will learn how to do that cool quote box thingy...
    leolaohoo wrote:I have an AP setup there using a 1 Watt booster and a 24db wire grid directional antenna.Oh my gosh.   I have seen something like this.  You say you have an amplifier/booster?  How is this connected to your WAP?  How LONG is the antenna cable (total) from your WAP to your booster and your booster to the antenna? I have an 8 inch pigtail connected between the AP and Booster.   It converts TNC from AP side to Type N on booster side.  Then a 50 coax cable running from booster to antennaWhen i upgraded to 50Mbit, i still only max out at 5mbit at Lb.Sorry, I don't want to sound so brash, but how did you measure this?  Did you by any chance measure this from WAP to WAP of from LAN-A to LAN-B?I simply tested the speed at Location A and at location B separately with speedtest.net, with the same laptop, testing to the same server on speedtest. Cable Modem > RVO42 Router > Laptop for test at location A Cable Modem > RVO42 Router > 1200 AP > Antennas and all that invisible stuff > 1200 WGB > SG100D-08 Switch > Laptop for test at location B

  • Switching to mac, questions on best place to host reference masters

    I am getting ready to switch from PC to Mac and have a question I am hoping I could get some advice on (I have a lot of questions actually, but will start with this one).
    I have a large library of photos and videos and plan on getting an imac for my wife and macbook pro for me (I do the tagging/organizing and video editing).
    Based on what I read, I am planning on keeping the masters on a separate drive and the aperture library on my macbook pro.
    Question is, am I better off keeping the masters on the imac and access that folder as an external folder on my macbook pro for the masters, or should I use a NAS drive for them?
    I have an older NAS that I can probably reformat for this purpose, but I often run into complications using a NAS (offsite backup issues, connectivity issues, can't use Time Machine, ...) and have read on the forums about people having issues writing to files on NAS's...
    I have a buffalo terastation pro ii, it is about 3 years old.  It is 2 terabytes.  I would get the imac with 2 terabytes and the 256gig ssd drive so the 2 tera could be dedicated to media.
    Thanks in advance for any advice, appreciate it.
    Peter

    plampione wrote:
    I am about to buy the macs, so both the desktop and macbook pro will be fast.  I plan on buying the fastest processor, 8gig of ram on the macbook, debating 8 or 16 on the imac, though from the previous thread sounds like it should be 16, and ssd on both (imac with 256 ssd + 2 TB HD, macbook with 512 sad).
    I suggest ordering both Macs with the minimum RAM and adding 3rd party RAM yourself.  The task is trivial and will save you heaps.  I bought my iMac with 4GBs (that's two 2GB modules plus two empty slots), and then added two 4GB modules into the empty slots.  So I have 12GBs.  My plan is to try to live with just 12GBs until 8GB modules become affordable, and then replace the two original 2GB modules with two 8GB modules, bringing it to 24GBs.  If needed, I'd ultimately go to 32GBs by replacing the two 4GB modules I have just installed.
    I think the MacBook Pro (MBP) still has only two slots, so using 4GB modules, you are limited to 8GBs.  If the architecture of the MBP supports it, you may be able to go to 16GB when 8GB modules become affordable.  But you'd need to check this.
    - using an attached harddrive on the macbook pro - Definitely a reasonable idea, but I was hoping to be able to bring up the library from anywhere in the house.  I do have gigabit ethernet throughout the house and can wire in as needed, but again, was hoping to be able to sit on the sofa and do some tagging.
    Another way to achieve this still has your Aperture Library and Masters on the iMac as I recommended above.  You could use the MBP to share the screen of the iMac.  It's a standard OS X function, no software to buy.  You enable sharing on the iMac and log in from the MBP.  That way you have the function on your sofa, but the power and capacity of the iMac for your actual work.  This works fine over wifi for me via an Airport Extreme using 802.11N
    - Backup - by putting the masters on the imac i was planning on using time machine to back them up onsite, and crashplan to backup offsite.
    Good plan.  TM and Crashplan are good products and free.
    I'd also recommend making a second onsite backup by cloning to a pair of external drives, and periodically send one of these drives offsite.  You may find that Crashplan for offsite backup over the internet is too slow if you have a big photo shoot.
    What if I plug into the gigabit ethernet whenever I am going to run aperture?  Would that allow the imac/macbook model to work?  Concerned about the performance issues described above though, even for the machines themselves.  Would copying the library nightly to my wife's computer work?  How big does a 20+k library get with referenced masters?
    Size of the library depends on many factors such as choices for previews, and the amount of editing (adjustments) you do, but here is a data point.  I have 47K images, many RAW and the Library was about 60GBs, the referenced Masters another 280GBs.  I say "was" because I have let it grow by importing recent images into it.
    Today we are on PCs and I use windows live photo gallery and tag all my photos, which are stored on a NAS, my wife also runs WLPG and can see all the tagging I do.  This works pretty well and is simple, I just import from the camera, show all 'untagged' photos/videos, and tag them.  I also move them to a basic folder structure to be safe.
    I understand this is not as feasible on mac, and if you are wondering why I am switching, it is because I have been having a lot of stability problems with the pc's and have had enough.  I use iphones, ipads, and apple tv's.  Recently got a macbook air and really like it.  Just need to figure out how to manage the photo/video library.
    A lot of my concerns about your plan are because I'm impatient.  On my MBP, it was taking about 5 seconds to render each image as I reviewed them.  I typically take a very short time to tag the images, so the computer was slower then me.  Now, with the iMac, I'm the slow link in the chain.
    It may be that you are used to a leisurely tagging process, but I have no experience with WLPG.
    The great things about Aperture that I really love, having come from a Photoshop background are that Aperture is always non-destructive in its editing and it is non-modal in the UI.
    There is a price to be paid for non-destructive editing.  Aperture often has to go back to the Master and then apply your adjustments.  This takes resources.  But it saves you time.  And you don't have to muck around creating another external folder structure yourself, as it seems you do with WLPG.  I just import my images into "Projects" in Aperture (the Masters are Managed), and when I want to selectively change Managed Masters to Referenced Masters, I just tell Aperture to do this and that it should utilize my Project structure as the external folder structure.  Aperture does all the folder creation for me, yippee!
    Finally, you may even find that the MacBook Air is good enough to do the tagging on with the shared screen approach I mentioned above, and then maybe you don't have to buy a MBP.
    HTH.  Happy to discuss further

Maybe you are looking for